The view from Zacheta

The view from Zacheta
Włodzimierz Pawlak - Poles form the national flag
Visualizzazione post con etichetta Politics. Mostra tutti i post
Visualizzazione post con etichetta Politics. Mostra tutti i post

giovedì 6 novembre 2008

Goodbye NEOCONs!

Big thanks to Michael Sandel for writing this and to Thomas L. Friedman for reporting it in the New York Times - by far the greatest newspaper of all times... God Bless America!

“Taking office at a time of crisis doesn’t guarantee greatness, but it can be an occasion for it,” argued the Harvard University political philosopher Michael Sandel. “That was certainly the case with Lincoln, F.D.R. and Truman.” Part of F.D.R.’s greatness, though, “was that he gradually wove a new governing political philosophy — the New Deal — out of the rubble and political disarray of the economic depression he inherited.” Obama will need to do the same, but these things take time.

“F.D.R. did not run on the New Deal in 1932,” said Sandel. “He ran on balancing the budget. Like Obama, he did not take office with a clearly articulated governing philosophy. He arrived with a confident, activist spirit and experimented. Not until 1936 did we have a presidential campaign about the New Deal. What Obama’s equivalent will be, even he doesn’t know. It will emerge as he grapples with the economy, energy and America’s role in the world. These challenges are so great that he will only succeed if he is able to articulate a new politics of the common good”.

“… In this election, the American public rejected these narrow notions of the common good. Most people now accept that unfettered markets don’t serve the public good. Markets generate abundance, but they can also breed excessive insecurity and risk. Even before the financial meltdown, we’ve seen a massive shift of risk from corporations to the individual. Obama will have to reinvent government as an instrument of the common good — to regulate markets, to protect citizens against the risks of unemployment and ill health, to invest in energy independence.”

You can read the full NYT article by Thomas L. Friedman here.

lunedì 27 ottobre 2008

God is dead, Marx is dead, Friedman is dead... and I am not feeling too well, myself.

The last week my genius friend Bing - post-graduate student in Physics in the U.S. - who is knowledgeable about everything on earth (and out), was kind enough to agree on the old post on the Chicagoans Waterloo. It then started a short messages exchange that I am assembling here. It will be nice to read it in two years or twenty years and see how much we were wrong or right to be as concerned and hopeful for a change as we are now.

B: totally agree with your opinion!! maybe you've also seen this:

http://www.pbs.org/moyers/journal/10102008/watch.html

George Soros was Karl Popper's student at one point, perhaps that explains why he recognizes fundamentalisms / unquestioned ideologies with dubious assumptions when he sees one.. whether it's communist or liberal.. unlike most economists / speculators.. i've always thought that unfettered free market economics with the assumptions of society progressing due to rational actions done by self-interested individuals (plus the "trickle down" philosophy) and an infinitely elastic market don't seem quite correct.. but unlike in physics, there's only one experimental lab for economics, and we have to pay the price if the assumptions turn out to be wrong.. i guess Soros has a much better way of articulating this situation, that's why i'm going to buy his book!!

W: Hey Bing, thanks a lot for the link!I actually haven't seen it yet,which is kind of a shame I can say now...indeed,what he says is just a consequence of your neat (and amazingly synthesized) point on the misleading foundation of neoclassical economic theory - brought to his recent splendour by the fundamentalist Chicagoans - with the political support over the past decades of neo-conservative republicans and some lobbies. The firsts truly believed (or at least I like to think so) in markets left alone and the trickle-down economics, while the seconds were just doing their job, promoting their own interests at the political level. Soros' principal-agent dilemma argument at the end of the video is perhaps the strongest one... with devastating political implications. I really think he's right when he says that a new era is starting... How to say that... God is dead, Marx is dead, Friedman is dead... and I am not feeling too well, myself.

B:Maybe God is not yet dead.. time and again he's bounced back from near fatality.. and maybe now he's laughing at us and the crass bankers...
but yeah i can't help being shocked at how many billions of dollars governments can instantly pour into the Iraqi war (then) and collapsing banks (now), while the MORE pressing issues of humanity - global poverty and lack of access to basic healthcare and illiteracy - which could be comfortably dealt with by the same amounts of money are conveniently neglected.. even claiming they are too expensive to undertake, or "not in the national interest".
And financial engineering.. can everything always be solved by modelling phenomena? when the same modelling process makes significant assumptions on which variables can be ignored and what can't be.. it's WEIRD how in the very earliest books on economics people like Alfred Marshall had put humanitarian concerns first.. but economics books nowadays resemble mathematical tracts. maybe i'm wrong.


W:
I couldn't agree with you more, on every single point! Including the God's laugh...

Then Bing wrote a weighty poetry which I am not attaching now as I'd have to ask him first. However, it's good to remind how Bing and I met each other. We've only seen one night, at St.Gery in Brussels - perhaps during the pub crawl that the author of this blog organized with the rest of the Strangelovers Laison Committee for the new batch of EC trainees. He had come to Brussels to meet a friend he had studied with in Cambridge - physicist as well - who had just started the stage at the Commission. We quickly got into this conversation on how alienating it is the North American way of doing post-graduate studies, and from there we got on pretty quickly on everything, including all difficult things except our favourite Trappist beer. And it is always a great event when you meet such a person.

mercoledì 15 ottobre 2008

The Chicagoans Waterloo

I have always been a great estimator of Paul Krugman, this year Nobel Prize in Economics. My thesis started with a quotation of him and I liked the way he wrote, his style, quite unconventional to be an economist, although probably not in absolute terms, as my Canadian room mate Nathan - a sharp policy grad student highly trusted by the author of this blog when it comes to Anglo-Saxon culture - used to complain about his inability to write articles in a decent english...

However, for how much Krugman has criticized the Bush administration since he joined as op-ed the New York Times, I can't forget how much he was radical about the goodness of free trade and globalization when he was an academic, how he regarded it as always good for everyone no matter how, who and when you open to it. Something that could only be true if you see the world under the fundamentalist eyes of the Chicago School of Economics. Those eyes that do not have a clue about what is going on now with the financial crisis and worst of all do not have a clue about how to react. Exactly as the market orthodox elite stood silent and still after the crisis of the 1929.

As at that time it was an Englishman - John Maynard Keynes - who advised the then President of the United States Franklin Delano Roosevelt on how to get out of the mess, this time it was the British prime minister - Gordon Brown - who had the promptness to react firmly and rapidly to the crisis by showing so far the only possible - we can't know if it is the right one yet - emergency exit to the crisis. As the brand-new Nobel Laureate in economics neatly explains here. Probably, the editorial that eventually brought him to an early Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.

Hopefully, a first of a long list to "unconventional" economists after a couple of decades of Chicago triumph.

Diego Rivera - Affresco Murario - Detroit Industry, Parete Sud 1932-33.

“In Detroit’s Institute of fine arts there is a remarkable room whose walls are painted with four stunning murals by Diego Rivera. The Rivera murals, completed in 1933, show in considerable detail the operations of Ford’s River Rouge industrial complex – a giant facility that combined at a single site blast furnaces, rolling mills, engine casting, body stamping, and assembly of complete automobiles. … Although Rivera’s murals were intended as a celebration of the power of modern industry (and also, to his patron’s dismay, a condemnation of its brutality), they now have a decidedly archaic feel. Part of that sense of old-fashioned industry comes from the very degree of integration that seemed so impressive at the time. What are all those desperate operations doing in the same facilitiy? Why are they not being done at specialized places scattered around the globe?”
Paul Krugman, “Growing World Trade: Causes and Consequences”, 1995

lunedì 22 settembre 2008

Libertè Egalitè Compètition

Questo pezzo è stato scritto di ritorno a Vancouver nel Maggio 2006, dopo otto mesi in Canada e tre settimane in Europa. La versione originale la potete trovare su Gheminga. Mi sembrava giusto ripubblicarlo prima che il quarantennale del '68 finisse, così come la crisi di cui sotto. Un ricordo particolare non può non andare a Violina che nonostante le condizioni pietose in cui versavo dopo due semestri di graduate studies (chi ha studiato seriamente in Nord America sa) mi ha accompagnato in giro per Parigi per due settimane come se niente fosse e mi è sempre stata accanto, facendomi scoprire - come al solito - tutta la bellezza che solitamente mi sfugge.

Sarà stato il ritorno in Europa dove tutto è così vecchio e pesante. Sarà che dopo aver visto (gl)i Champes Elysèe con tutte quelle bandiere francesi tra alberi e negozi e la libreria della Sorbona murata e in ricostruzione e le facce della gente per strada, di quelli che hanno detto no alla costituzione europea, ma anche degli unici coetanei che riescono ancora a scendere in strada e protestare per qualcosa (e vincere)... Sarà che dove sono stati detenuti il re Luigi di turno e, poco dopo, Robespierre, prima di essere giustiziati, ci ho visto una mostra fotografica sulla Senna. Sarà che è un po’ che ho questo pensiero per la testa e mi chiedo: ma perché non sono nato negli anni ’50? C’era Elvis, che sarei stato troppo piccolo per apprezzare, ma c’era. E poi sarei cresciuto al tempo in cui lo showbiz, al limite, erano Beatles e Rolling Stones, con John Lennon che convive con Yoko Ono e scrive Imagine, con il periodo d’oro del rock‘n’roll. Magari sarei anche riuscito a vedere i Pink Floyd quando il genio, prima di impazzire e scomparire, era ancora tra loro sul palco. Avrei capito cosa vuol dire la parola punk e Jim Morrison non sarebbe stato un sosia di Val Kilmer. Avrei potuto passare giornate nei parchi con persone convinte che pace e amore siano due cose importanti, magari fumando un po’ di ganja o mangiando funghetti (senza eskimo per rispetto del profeta degli appennini). Gridare spensierato a vent’anni che le vie da percorrere per un mondo migliore passavano per forza attraverso la giustizia sociale (e cioè che anche l’operaio vuole il figlio dottore), che voglio tutto e subito. E la cosa bella è che ci avrei creduto. Avrei creduto in tutto questo. Sarei vissuto nell’epoca in cui l’immaginario collettivo del migliore dei mondi possibili non era di molto lontano da quello dei cartoni animati, dove con idee semplici si rispondeva a problemi complessi. Con buona pace del materialismo storico e della critica marxista (interessante contraltare di tutta questa leggerezza, peccato che si sarebbe rivelata totalmente sbagliata come la storia meglio di chiunque altro ha inesorabilmente dimostrato). Ed invece sono nato negli anni ’80, con trenta anni di ritardo su quel mondo in cui, nonostante tutto, mi avevano preparato a vivere. Libertè, Egalitè, Compètition. Uno slogan postmoderno, non poteva essere altrimenti. Suona piuttosto bene, ma è difficile da gridare. In tre parole quel tanto famigerato e frainteso ideale che è anche l’unica vera novità concettuale della mia generazione: il mercato. Chi mi sa spiegare perché mi han regalato tre volte "Never Mind" e mai "The dark side of the moon"?